Carrot Cake: Method, Frosting and Variations

Looking for a carrot cake recipe that stays moist and doesn’t fuss? Mix an oil-based batter, bake it until golden, cool it fully, then top it with cream cheese frosting. For more ideas to serve beside this cake, browse the…

carrot cake recipe

Looking for a carrot cake recipe that stays moist and doesn’t fuss? Mix an oil-based batter, bake it until golden, cool it fully, then top it with cream cheese frosting.

For more ideas to serve beside this cake, browse the easy dessert recipes collection.

Item Value
Oven temperature 350°F
Bake time, 9×13-inch sheet cake 40-45 minutes
Carrots needed About 4 medium carrots for 3 cups grated
Layer cake option Two 8-inch round pans, about 25-35 minutes
Freezer storage Use within 1-2 months

These figures come from Seasons and Suppers and Reluctant Entertainer. Recipes differ from site to site and figures can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Why carrot cake is made with oil, not butter

Classic versions are oil-based rather than butter-based. Reluctant Entertainer explains that the oil keeps the cake moist and helps it last for days.

Seasons and Suppers makes the same point for a sheet cake: no butter is needed, and the crumb stays soft for days. It names vegetable oil as its preference and lists canola or sunflower as similar neutral oils.

Not every oil works. Well Seasoned Studio says not to substitute olive oil, though other neutral oils or even coconut oil are open to experiment.

Sugar does more than sweeten. According to Seasons and Suppers, sugar contributes to texture, shelf-life and browning, so cutting it back changes more than the taste.

Ingredients and what to choose

The batter relies on pantry staples plus grated carrots and a handful of nuts. These are the choices worth making deliberately:

  • Carrots: Seasons and Suppers says about 4 medium carrots make 3 cups of grated carrot. Baked by Rachel recommends grating them finely instead of using the standard thick option.
  • Flour: use regular all-purpose flour and measure it with the stir, spoon and level method, as Seasons and Suppers advises.
  • Nuts: walnuts are the classic pairing, and pecans or no nuts at all also work, per Seasons and Suppers. Well Seasoned Studio suggests toasting walnuts in a dry skillet to bring out their flavor.
  • Measuring: the same Well Seasoned Studio page stresses correct ratios and recommends a scale for best results.

Recipes disagree on sweeteners. Well Seasoned Studio reports that granulated and brown sugar together gave the best texture, while Reluctant Entertainer credits brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg for its rich flavors, and Seasons and Suppers sticks to white sugar and cinnamon.

Method for a sheet cake

A sheet cake is the simplest format, because it needs one pan, one bowl for the batter and no layering. Follow these steps in order:

  1. Heat the oven to 350°F, per Reluctant Entertainer, and prepare a 9×13-inch pan as Seasons and Suppers does. Baked by Rachel adds a parchment sheet with some overhang for lifting, and warns against olive oil or savory cooking spray on the pan.
  2. Stir the flour, cinnamon, baking soda, baking powder and salt together in a bowl and set it aside, following Reluctant Entertainer.
  3. Beat the sugar and oil for about 1 minute with an electric mixer, then add the grated carrots and eggs, as in the Seasons and Suppers method. Add the dry mixture and nuts last.
  4. Mix only until no flour streaks remain, because Well Seasoned Studio warns against overmixing once the flour goes in.
  5. Level the batter and bake for 40-45 minutes, until evenly golden and pulling away from the sides, according to Seasons and Suppers. A dark pan cooks faster, so check it a little earlier.
  6. Let the cake cool completely before frosting. Any warmth left in it will melt the icing.

To confirm the cake is done, Well Seasoned Studio says a cake tester in the center should come out clean or with a few crumbs. Gently pressing the top is a second check: if it springs back, the cake is baked through.

A frosted slice of orange-colored cake topped with a carrot decoration sits beside whole carrots.

Cream cheese frosting: texture and timing

The topping is built from cream cheese, butter, vanilla and confectioners’ sugar. Seasons and Suppers beats the room temperature cream cheese, butter and vanilla until creamy before adding the icing sugar.

Once the sugar is in, the same page mixes on low until combined, then increases the speed for a minute until the frosting turns light and fluffy. It also warns that cream cheese takes a surprisingly long time to reach room temperature, so take it out of the refrigerator early.

Presentation is flexible. Reluctant Entertainer serves the cake deconstructed, with the frosting on the side, and says to keep any unused frosting refrigerated.

If cream cheese isn’t to hand, Seasons and Suppers suggests a simple buttercream flavored with cinnamon, lemon or orange. Read up on how to make buttercream before you take that route.

Variations on the basic cake

The same batter adapts to other pans, and small swaps are possible when you accept that the result may differ from the tested version.

  • Smaller cake: Seasons and Suppers says you can halve the recipe and bake it in an 8×8-inch pan.
  • Layer cake: Seasons and Suppers bakes the batter in two 8-inch round pans for about 25-35 minutes. Its icing suits a naked-type cake, and a thick coat over the whole cake may need more than double.
  • Bundt: Reluctant Entertainer greases a 10-inch Bundt pan, bakes for 45-60 minutes, and cools the cake completely before removing it from the pan.
  • Applesauce: Baked by Rachel recommends swapping out no more than half of the oil for it.
  • Gluten free: Baked by Rachel allows a 1:1 gluten free flour, with the caveat that it tested only all-purpose flour.

Planning a wider spread? The millionaire’s shortbread recipe gives you a contrasting tray bake to serve beside this cake.

Storing and freezing carrot cake

Once iced, Seasons and Suppers says the cake should be refrigerated. Baked by Rachel adds that in warmer environments the refrigerator is the only place to keep it.

The cake can also be frozen. Seasons and Suppers says it freezes well before or after icing, wrapped tightly and used within 1-2 months, then thawed in the refrigerator because of the frosting.

Baked by Rachel prefers to freeze the cake without frosting. It then thaws the cake fully in the refrigerator and brings it to room temperature before frosting.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to peel the carrots?

Show answer

Yes, according to Reluctant Entertainer, because the skin can taste bitter. Peel them before grating for the best flavor.

Can I use pre-shredded carrots?

Show answer

Reluctant Entertainer recommends already shredded carrots for easy making. Well Seasoned Studio prefers a box grater but calls store-bought acceptable.

Can I turn the batter into cupcakes?

Show answer

Sources split on this. Well Seasoned Studio says the same batter can become cupcakes, while Baked by Rachel says its version was written for and tested only as a single layer cake.

Can I add raisins, pineapple or coconut?

Show answer

Seasons and Suppers allows them but advises restraint so the crumb isn’t weighed down. Well Seasoned Studio notes that a cake with pineapple or coconut is a hummingbird cake.

How do I get clean slices?

Show answer

A clean knife is key, according to Baked by Rachel. Wipe the blade on a paper towel, or rinse and dry it, between every slice.

❧